Thornton Wilder’s Our Town, a play about ordinary people and ordinary life in a small New England town at the beginning of the twentieth century, was an immediate success when it first appeared on stage in 1938. It won a Pulitzer prize and has become an enduring favorite.
Hollywood turned out an ambitious film adaptation in 1940 that starred Martha Scott, who played the role of Emily in the original stage presentation, and a young William Holden played George, the boy next door.
The film garnered six Academy Award nominations including best picture. Composer Aaron Copland’s musical score also received a nomination. However, the film received mixed critical reaction, especially since the play’s ending was altered. I originally thought the Hollywood studio balked at the sad ending, but now I know that playwright Wilder decided that the original ending would be too overpowering on the large screen. It is available for viewing on You Tube or DVD with Copland's musical score.
A made for TV version of Our Town that starred Paul Newman as the Stage Manager provides a somewhat different viewing experience. This 2003 version is not really a film adaptation but a filming of an actual stage performance that was originally performed at the Westport, Country Playhouse in Connecticut.
Newman and his wife, actress Joanne Woodward, longtime residents of Westport, came out of retirement to work on the classic play. Newman was coaxed to return to the stage after a 38-year absence, and Woodward produced.
This version of the play, directed expertly by James Naughton, is very true to the original. We see a sparse uncluttered stage where most of the incidental details are left to our imagination. The elderly Newman’s subdued performance matches anything he ever did in his illustrious film career. He is surrounded by a cast of relative unknowns who all turn in fine performances, especially the actresses who play the two mothers.
As mentioned above the play premiered in 1938, the same year that George Bernard Shaw’s Pygmalion received its fine film treatment. In Pygmalion, Shaw heaped criticism on prevailing social norms and conventional morality as he turns an illiterate Cockney street vendor into a lady. In Our Town, Thornton Wilder did the opposite, and his play is a homage to the traditional mores and morality that have ennobled ordinary people.
The expert acting of the mothers and fathers in the play demonstrates the true nobility of their characters, and at one point the Stage Manager even steps in to utter a homage to the American housewife.
No one needs to transform the heroine into a lady. At seventeen Emily already is one, albeit without title. In one pivotal scene, she tells her boyfriend, George, that she is disappointed with his behavior. He is Senior class president and star baseball player but has become self-centered to the point where he takes her and his own family for granted. She expects him to be “perfect” and when he replies that she is perhaps asking too much, she replies that her father is perfect, and that as far as she knows, his own father, the town doctor, is perfect. An unforgettable scene ensues at the drugstore soda fountain. George thanks Emily for pointing out “the flaw in his character,” and hopes that he can live up to her expectations. The scene is played beautifully in both versions.
Whatever the outcome of the curriculum debates going on in today’s schools, Our Town should be required reading and viewing for every American. The Westport Country playhouse version originally appeared on PBS in 2003, but our public television network should take pains to feature it every year at Thanksgiving time.
###



